smallroomsoftware.com

Toasted hard drive and Apple rant..

Posted on December 04, 2006

My 10 year, disk-crash free run came to an end the other day when my 6 month old MacBook decided not to reboot and to present me with the old blinking question mark. After a day of fiddling the disk still showed no signs of life. As far as my MacBook is concerned, the disk is not even plugged in. Not a good sign I think. Having pretty much survived data-loss free since I started using computers I've become pretty blase about back-ups. Most of my paid work is checked in to one or another subversion repository but I have some private documents, photos not on flickr and other random old stuff that may be lost. Needless to say I'm now investigating backup strategies, to be implemented when I get home.

I have realised that if you have a drive failure there is really no point in using the Apple warrantee. Apple's customer service continues to go downhill. Phone Apple and (after you spend 15 minutes telling them who you are and giving them your credit-card number) the best offer of assistance you will get is a suggestion to take it to an authorized dealer for repair. Couriering your laptop for repair appears to be a thing of the past. I asked the guy if paid up AppleCare would get me by-post delivery. Apparently it doesn't! Then what on earth is the point in purchasing AppleCare? It's a shame because I know a lot of people who have recently converted to Apple from the more respectable PC manufacturers and I suspect they would pretty amazed at the lack of support should their machine fail. Especially when some of them have bought AppleCare. I asked about getting a new disk sent out for a DIY repair (as advertised on Apple's site). The guy told me that Apple "didn't do that anymore". It's a real shame if Apple are abandoning the DIY repair scheme. It worked nicely for my iMac. I replace a mainboard and an inverter without having to let go of my machine for 2 weeks.

The trouble seems to be that Apple's warrantee and even AppleCare terms are rather non-specific. They state that "repair service may include onsite, carry-in, and direct mail-in; specific availability of each option depends on product type and location of Apple Authorized Service Provider". Finding out what repair option you are entitled to is impossible and probably just depends on who you happen to talk to on the phone.

Comments
  1. Sam DeaneDecember 11, 2006 @ 10:49 AM
    Hi Tom, Funnily enough I had a similar failure recently on my G4 powerbook - hard drive completely totalled. I've been using Macs since 1989 and it's the first time I've ever had a drive give up on me. I've also had problems with the dvd drive in my new MacBook, and was told by the AppleCare folks that I had to go round and deliver the laptop in person to my local repair shop. As you say, one wonders exactly what one is paying for...
  2. MarkusDecember 15, 2006 @ 11:20 AM
    Hi Tom! Thanks for this blog entry. For my next purchase I will reconsider not to buy AppleCare if it is useless. At the end of the day it is a lot of money. Michael as far as I know had a very good experience with AppleCare in the past, but that might have changed :( Apple is a big company, so it wouldn't cost them too much to keep the support at a good level or even push it to the best on the market. That is what people want today isn't it ? Tom, when are you considering to come back to the UK (ever) ? Best regards from Cambridge. Markus
  3. tomDecember 15, 2006 @ 11:37 AM
    Yeah lots of people I know have had a good experience in the past. I wouldn't mind paying a bit more for a guaranteed level of support. Even if it was limited to one speedy repair job. Or just paying a small fee to get it fixed quickly by post. The DIY parts thing seemed good to me too. I'm flying back today. Yesterday I managed to just miss the check-in deadline and they wouldn't let me through. You can get a bit blasé with these short flights. I now have a faster 7200 rpm sata drive waiting for me at home. I'm hoping the extra cost will be worth it! tom
  4. mattMarch 20, 2007 @ 08:00 PM
    I've had nothing but negative experiences with Apple tech support, all the way back to my first mac (1999). I had actually sworn off Apple products until i bought a shuffle and then a few more iPods... But when iTunes deleted a bunch of purchased music off of my iPod and Apple informed me that it would only replace the songs that were still available via the iTunes store, I realized that the overall level of tech support is still abysmal. The bright side appears to be that Apple is making better products these days, but heaven forbid you have trouble, it becomes clear that Apple hates being in the tech support business and just doesn't take it seriously. I waited on hold for 15 minutes only to find out that all iPod phone support has been discontinued. Why offer a position for iPod in the phone menu if there is no support available? Turns out they do have email support, but so far I have just been told that I should have backed up my library more carefully. Shame on me, I guess. But every time I look at the shiny bright display on one of the new macbooks I think that maybe I'll get one when I am ready for a new laptop... but stories like yours chasten that urge.
Post a comment
Comment



If you can read this, you don't use a typical webbrowser that plays nice with CSS.
Please do not fill in anything here!



Hosting by site5.com